Saturday, June 12, 2010

Newkirk Chapters 2 & 8



The abundant research on medical decision making illluminates the responses of doctors and nurses who (like teachers) find themselves in complex environments that require far more than the application of research. In other words, each situation is, to a considerable degree, a unique experience that can't be anticipated by a preset procedure. Professionals often work in environments where "problems are interconnected, environments are turbulent, and the future is indeterminate" (Schon 1983,16). Classroom teachers will recognize this description. Classrooms are complex environments-"messes"- in which teachers must deal with uncertainty, instability, uniqueness, and completing values. It is little wonder that teachers are skeptical of guidelines and prescriptions that fail to account for this complexity.

Teachers' resistance to research and that which is termed theory by academicians comes not from a belief that this work is inaccurate-only that it is too general to be useful in the situations they find themselves. It exists at a level of abstraction that they fail to find useful as they deal with the complex "messes" of classroom life. To do their work requires a particularized, situated, child-specific, class-specific, day-specific, school-specific form of knowledge-often intuitive and unarticulated- that is rarely considered to be theory at all. In the hierarchical models of professional knowledge, this localized knowledge never has the status accorded to research or abstract theorizing. The teachers' place at the bottom of the hierarchy is secure- they deliver instruction. (pages 27-29)

Newkirk continues (in chapter eight) to consider a counter-narrative to the "heroic, exemplary self-sacrificing" teacher narrative portrayed in the media outlets such as in the movie Stand and Deliver. From a psychoanalytic perspective, these narratives present a very narcissistic image of teaching, an inflated self-presentation, even self-admiration-that leave teachers vulnerable to psychological pain when they receive criticism or experience difficulty (or feel emotions) incompatible with this self-image. And to the extent that, as a culture, we treat these depictions of selfless teaching as an ideal, those (like me) who fall short also feel inadequate, and I will argue, lose some pleasure that might come from a more realistic vision of teaching, with its small victories and small advances. (pages 159-160)

The term resonate will be used throughout the Summer Institute as a term that refers to "what strikes a chord with you". What do you agree with and what do you push back against? What resonates with you regarding Newkirks' statements on the practical applications of research/theory in the classroom and/or the "heroic, exemplary self-sacrificing" teacher narrative?

Monday, May 31, 2010

Newkirk Chapters 1 & 7



Standardization and standards seem so linguistically close that one shades into the other. It may be that there is something aesthetically pleasing in uniform action-the pleasure of watching a drill team, for example. Yet standardization only leads to sameness, not necessarily quality, and rarely to excellence. This book, then, will challenge a growing trend in education that requires teachers to work in preestablished (invariably "research-based") systems that sharply limit their capacity to make decisions about curriculum and students. Schools are not factories; students are not products. (page 9-10)

The history of writing instruction in this country is really a history of writinglike activities (particularly spelling, grammar instruction) taking the place of writing itself.

A related force that works against writing (and to some extent reading) is commodification- the tendency to think of education in terms of products and materials. Schools don't develop programs or create them- they purchase them. From the standpoint of marketability, writing instruction is a poor bet. If, as Donald Murray argued, the main texts in writing classes are the ones students are producing, the only real market is for blank paper. One might argue that these skills materials and workbooks teach the "building blocks" for writing, but too often these building blocks simply substitute for actual writing, displacing it altogether for students in lower tracks (one prominent researcher estimated that some disadvantaged students may write no more than five hundred words of actual writing in a year).

As James Moffett notes, one tactic used by producers of materials is mystification- the implied argument that writing is so technical a subject, so tangled with complex alignments to standards and research, so intricate in its sequence of skills development, so integrated with lessons in punctuation/grammar/genres, so dependent on complex assessments, that no single teacher could possibly construct his or her own system. A teacher would feel naked indeed to presume to teach writing without the support of these systems. (page 137-139)

What writing curriculum materials impact your writing instruction? What are your thoughts on the "mystification" of writing and how you were taught to write or teach writing to others?

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Newkirk Chapter 4 & 5



The most compelling argument for a new valuation of popular culture in children's writing comes in the profoundly important line of research carried out by Ann Haas Dyson (1997, 2003) in urban, and often low-income, schools. The core ethical theme running through Dyson's work concerns access: If these cultural resources are dismissed for whatever reason (too exploitative, too commercial, too tied to television, to "low class"), if the middle/professional-class type of book culture is perceived as the only useful literacy experience, the result is profoundly alienating and inequitable. (p. 96)

There are consequences to this censorship.

The facts of literacy development are plain for all to see: boys fall dramatically behind girls in reading, and particularly writing, by the third grade. Those boys who have the experience of being behind, of not being good at literacy - and they number in the millions - soon turn a difficulty into an identity.

They begin to believe that they are just not good at words, at least printed ones. Such an identity provides security because there is no longer a need to really try, for any attempt just exposes a deficiency. And because we all have a stake in the identities we assume (even when they work against us), they are much more impervious to instruction.

These students are the ones who claim that "reading is stupid", the ones who perfect avoidance strategies, who are always breaking their pencils, who manage to write only a few primer-level sentences in writing period, and who later manage to pass English with the help of Sparknotes.

Thus we have a negative cycle: Boys experience difficulty and, early on, come to avoid reading and writing- and because they avoid it, they experience even greater difficulty, to the point where faking it is the only reasonable solution. I would suggest that the consequences of opting out of reading and writing - in an "information age" where work involves working with texts more than raw materials- are severe indeed. (p. 105-106)

Newkirk argues for a wider view of literacy and literate practices in school. In your own experience and/or opinion how can we find ways to bridge the literacies from boys (and girls who don't identify with "school literacy") lives with the literacies we would like them to practice, valuing both equally?

Sunday, April 11, 2010

Newkirk Chapters 3 & 6



Newkirk proposes that the biggest story in literacy development is not that students fail to learn to read and write (though some do and they deserve special attention and help), but that they soon perceive school literacy as alienating work.

Students develop "basic" skills but millions don't progress from there. As they move through school, studies show, they do less and less reading and writing voluntarily. Any effort to teach analytic or reflective literacy skill is built on the premise of engagement, for analysis is unpacking of our reactions and involvement. (p.129)

What are your thoughts regarding this assertion by Newkirk?